Showing posts with label Miranda Devine. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miranda Devine. Show all posts

Monday, October 18, 2010

A Bolt from the Green

Andrew Bolt is interesting to contrast with Miranda Devine, in that he shows none of the flair or panache so keenly demonstrated by the latter. Each time Devine is set loose on a topic, she sinks her teeth in and rips it to pieces, not caring how she savages it, content to know that people have been told.

In comparison, Bolt is merely lazy. His output on his blog is nothing short of prodigious, but the majority of it is a link to something that he finds objectionable, then a sentence or two amounting to little more than “this is lies! Damned lies and fabrication!” (Poor grammar simulated for effect). You have to wade through a morass of these items to actually discover his columns, or anything of substance –and I use that term loosely.

Five reasons not to trust this jihad against our farmers” gets the title right, at least: inflammatory, discriminatory, and predicated on a lie. He’s doing his bit for right wing opinion-holders everywhere. Sadly, Bolt has forgotten how to write. Almost every paragraph is a mere sentence long, and none of them are interesting. The most damning quote, from Frank Sartor, has been plainly denied by its alleged source.

Bolt is content to throw meaningless figures at the audience, provided by “furious” interest groups, and then somehow tie them together by suggesting that it’s all part of a “green conspiracy”. Bolt is entirely unaware of the fact that he’s using the language of fear to suggest that environmentalists have embarked on a fear campaign based on science that he considers “dodgy” at best.

Bolt’s work is eminently forgettable, to the point that one would be hardpressed to remember, by the end, why they had started reading in the first place. The problem is this: with the plainly superior Miranda Devine now comfortably installed at News Ltd, what is the use of carrying Bolt’s dead weight? The Melbourne/Sydney divide isn’t as important as it used to be: the internet lacks frontiers.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

It ain't easy being Devine

Much as it pains me to say this (and this is an area in which I am not able to maintain a veneer of bipartisanship), Miranda Devine (Miranda Devine!) understands the internet better than Jonathan Green could ever hope to.

“Frannie and friends removed the video from the 10:10 website when complaints started, but it was too late. She has let the cat out of the bag.”

Devine is cognizant of the fact that nothing on the internet ever dies, which is why I’m able to link you to this absolutely abhorrent piece that she wrote in 2007 conflating The History Boys with pedophilia.

That aside, it’s time to actually address her premiere blog post in her new home on the Herald Sun blogs, “What it really means to be Green”. Devine starts with an easy target, Richard Curtis’ “10:10 No Pressure” video:





The problem is that Devine has chosen to take this ill-advised (and, more offensively, boring) video as a serious indication of the actual leanings of environmentally minded people: she sincerely believes that Greens are determined to kill everyone. This is not even paraphrasing her and twisting her words: she has literally referred to greens as a “totalitarian death cult”, and makes repeated references to Nazism. She takes everything to such extremes that it’s difficult to take her seriously, but she absolutely wants you to.

Devine’s work is actually a perfect piece of opinion writing, online or off. It is tempting to simply quote the entire thing because, regardless of what you actually think of her opinions, she is a master craftswoman of the form. She writes polemics, and people can’t help but be inflamed by them (or, somehow, agree with them).

Miranda Devine earns her money, and she is clearly more at home in her new News Limited digs than she ever was at Fairfax. Godspeed, Miranda. Never stop doing what you do.